Data for 2023
Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration, 2023
2023, as V-Dem Institute’s 2026 release gives it · stored as published, never rewritten
V-Dem's measure of meritocratic appointment asks whether people are hired, promoted and fired in a country's civil service on the strength of their skills and merit, or through personal and political connections. It is an expert-coded estimate on an open-ended scale centred near zero, and a higher figure means more appointments on merit.
Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration, 2023 covers 176 countries. Singapore is highest, at 3.099; Belarus is lowest, at -2.367. The middle country reads 0.334. Against 2022, 56 values changed (32 up, 24 down), the same countries are covered.
Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration · Data for 2023
HighestSingapore
3.099LowestBelarus
-2.367Shaded by value in five groups of equal size, darkest at the better end.
01Position · derived
The table
Every country and every column of Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration, 2023, as published. V-Dem Institute ranks nobody on this measure; the position is derived here by ordering the published values. “=” marks a shared position.
Showing 25 of 176 countries · select a heading to sort
| derived | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1 | SGPSouth-eastern Asia | 3.099 |
| 2 | ESTNorthern Europe | 2.768 |
| 3 | DEUWestern Europe | 2.743 |
| 4 | DNKNorthern Europe | 2.691 |
| 5 | LUXWestern Europe | 2.374 |
| 6 | GBRNorthern Europe | 2.357 |
| 7 | KOREastern Asia | 2.326 |
| 8 | NORNorthern Europe | 2.323 |
| 9 | NZLAustralia and New Zealand | 2.219 |
| 10 | LVANorthern Europe | 2.171 |
| 11 | AUSAustralia and New Zealand | 2.150 |
| 12 | NLDWestern Europe | 2.148 |
| 13 | IRLNorthern Europe | 2.051 |
| 14 | CHLSouth America | 2.012 |
| 15 | FRAWestern Europe | 1.985 |
| 16 | SWENorthern Europe | 1.959 |
| 17 | CZEEastern Europe | 1.920 |
| 18 | BGREastern Europe | 1.908 |
| 19 | ISLNorthern Europe | 1.891 |
| 20 | URYSouth America | 1.852 |
| 21 | BTNSouthern Asia | 1.847 |
| 22 | ISRWestern Asia | 1.748 |
| 23 | USANorthern America | 1.739 |
| 24 | JPNEastern Asia | 1.737 |
| 25 | TWNEastern Asia | 1.721 |
| 26 | AREWestern Asia | 1.718 |
| 27 | CANNorthern America | 1.660 |
| 28 | ESPSouthern Europe | 1.639 |
| 29 | ITASouthern Europe | 1.525 |
| 30 | FINNorthern Europe | 1.520 |
| 31 | MDVSouthern Asia | 1.503 |
| 32 | LTUNorthern Europe | 1.450 |
| 33 | SYCEastern Africa | 1.401 |
| 34 | BELWestern Europe | 1.399 |
| 35 | HKGEastern Asia | 1.393 |
| 36 | THASouth-eastern Asia | 1.366 |
| 37 | CHEWestern Europe | 1.363 |
| 38 | BRASouth America | 1.345 |
| 39 | CRICentral America | 1.325 |
| 40 | BENWestern Africa | 1.314 |
| 41 | SVKEastern Europe | 1.270 |
| 42 | MYSSouth-eastern Asia | 1.241 |
| =43 | BRBCaribbean | 1.201 |
| =43 | GRCSouthern Europe | 1.201 |
| 45 | VUTMelanesia | 1.169 |
| 46 | IDNSouth-eastern Asia | 1.152 |
| =47 | GMBWestern Africa | 1.137 |
| =47 | JAMCaribbean | 1.137 |
| 49 | CYPWestern Asia | 1.097 |
| 50 | PRTSouthern Europe | 1.095 |
| 51 | SVNSouthern Europe | 1.085 |
| 52 | MLTSouthern Europe | 1.029 |
| 53 | ARGSouth America | 1.028 |
| 54 | AUTWestern Europe | 1.009 |
| 55 | LKASouthern Asia | 0.996 |
| 56 | NGAWestern Africa | 0.994 |
| 57 | UGAEastern Africa | 0.941 |
| 58 | BIHSouthern Europe | 0.935 |
| 59 | MNESouthern Europe | 0.934 |
| 60 | NPLSouthern Asia | 0.912 |
| 61 | INDSouthern Asia | 0.855 |
| 62 | ZMBEastern Africa | 0.827 |
| 63 | BFAWestern Africa | 0.811 |
| 64 | ZAFSouthern Africa | 0.782 |
| 65 | FJIMelanesia | 0.765 |
| 66 | SLBMelanesia | 0.754 |
| 67 | NAMSouthern Africa | 0.736 |
| 68 | PHLSouth-eastern Asia | 0.710 |
| 69 | BWASouthern Africa | 0.707 |
| 70 | TTOCaribbean | 0.650 |
| 71 | PNGMelanesia | 0.639 |
| 72 | SRBSouthern Europe | 0.625 |
| 73 | RUSEastern Europe | 0.620 |
| 74 | DOMCaribbean | 0.575 |
| 75 | COLSouth America | 0.570 |
| 76 | IRNSouthern Asia | 0.543 |
| 77 | TZAEastern Africa | 0.515 |
| 78 | MWIEastern Africa | 0.506 |
| 79 | XKXSouthern Europe | 0.490 |
| 80 | ZWEEastern Africa | 0.436 |
| 81 | PANCentral America | 0.418 |
| 82 | BOLSouth America | 0.413 |
| 83 | KENEastern Africa | 0.393 |
| 84 | OMNWestern Asia | 0.385 |
| 85 | HUNEastern Europe | 0.368 |
| 86 | MLIWestern Africa | 0.361 |
| 87 | JORWestern Asia | 0.345 |
| 88 | VNMSouth-eastern Asia | 0.339 |
| 89 | PAKSouthern Asia | 0.328 |
| 90 | CHNEastern Asia | 0.321 |
| 91 | PRKEastern Asia | 0.318 |
| 92 | PERSouth America | 0.298 |
| 93 | MUSEastern Africa | 0.296 |
| 94 | DZANorthern Africa | 0.276 |
| 95 | TUNNorthern Africa | 0.252 |
| 96 | KAZCentral Asia | 0.251 |
| 97 | MARNorthern Africa | 0.239 |
| 98 | COGMiddle Africa | 0.197 |
| 99 | COMEastern Africa | 0.184 |
| 100 | BGDSouthern Asia | 0.176 |
| 101 | SomalilandXSLEastern Africa | 0.116 |
| 102 | RWAEastern Africa | 0.108 |
| 103 | KGZCentral Asia | 0.089 |
| 104 | SURSouth America | 0.059 |
| 105 | TGOWestern Africa | 0.041 |
| 106 | SENWestern Africa | 0.019 |
| 107 | LSOSouthern Africa | 0.009 |
| 108 | KWTWestern Asia | -0.016 |
| 109 | POLEastern Europe | -0.029 |
| 110 | NERWestern Africa | -0.032 |
| 111 | GHAWestern Africa | -0.051 |
| 112 | SWZSouthern Africa | -0.062 |
| 113 | AGOMiddle Africa | -0.076 |
| 114 | DJIEastern Africa | -0.098 |
| 115 | GUYSouth America | -0.108 |
| 116 | TLSSouth-eastern Asia | -0.117 |
| 117 | LBRWestern Africa | -0.123 |
| 118 | HNDCentral America | -0.157 |
| 119 | LAOSouth-eastern Asia | -0.161 |
| 120 | CPVWestern Africa | -0.174 |
| 121 | GEOWestern Asia | -0.246 |
| 122 | HRVSouthern Europe | -0.278 |
| 123 | UZBCentral Asia | -0.281 |
| 124 | UKREastern Europe | -0.291 |
| 125 | MNGEastern Asia | -0.299 |
| 126 | GABMiddle Africa | -0.337 |
| 127 | ECUSouth America | -0.358 |
| 128 | STPMiddle Africa | -0.431 |
| 129 | MEXCentral America | -0.435 |
| 130 | MKDSouthern Europe | -0.463 |
| 131 | SAUWestern Asia | -0.492 |
| 132 | BHRWestern Asia | -0.521 |
| 133 | CIVWestern Africa | -0.528 |
| 134 | MDGEastern Africa | -0.551 |
| 135 | MDAEastern Europe | -0.572 |
| 136 | MOZEastern Africa | -0.603 |
| 137 | SLEWestern Africa | -0.630 |
| 138 | ETHEastern Africa | -0.668 |
| 139 | GNBWestern Africa | -0.688 |
| 140 | IRQWestern Asia | -0.690 |
| 141 | KHMSouth-eastern Asia | -0.735 |
| 142 | GTMCentral America | -0.761 |
| 143 | TCDMiddle Africa | -0.769 |
| 144 | CODMiddle Africa | -0.788 |
| 145 | TURWestern Asia | -0.815 |
| 146 | HTICaribbean | -0.864 |
| 147 | PRYSouth America | -0.902 |
| =148 | AZEWestern Asia | -0.917 |
| =148 | LBNWestern Asia | -0.917 |
| 150 | ARMWestern Asia | -0.952 |
| 151 | ALBSouthern Europe | -0.957 |
| 152 | ROUEastern Europe | -0.972 |
| 153 | SOMEastern Africa | -1.002 |
| 154 | SLVCentral America | -1.080 |
| 155 | MMRSouth-eastern Asia | -1.106 |
| 156 | GINWestern Africa | -1.123 |
| 157 | EGYNorthern Africa | -1.196 |
| 158 | CAFMiddle Africa | -1.218 |
| 159 | CMRMiddle Africa | -1.276 |
| 160 | TJKCentral Asia | -1.291 |
| 161 | YEMWestern Asia | -1.308 |
| 162 | MRTWestern Africa | -1.310 |
| 163 | SSDEastern Africa | -1.337 |
| 164 | SYRWestern Asia | -1.513 |
| 165 | GNQMiddle Africa | -1.565 |
| 166 | CUBCaribbean | -1.568 |
| 167 | VENSouth America | -1.662 |
| 168 | BDIEastern Africa | -1.676 |
| 169 | LBYNorthern Africa | -1.739 |
| 170 | QATWestern Asia | -1.806 |
| 171 | NICCentral America | -1.831 |
| 172 | ERIEastern Africa | -1.832 |
| 173 | TKMCentral Asia | -1.893 |
| 174 | SDNNorthern Africa | -2.015 |
| 175 | AFGSouthern Asia | -2.172 |
| 176 | BLREastern Europe | -2.367 |
02In 2023
At either end
The 5 countries at each end of the headline.
Highest
- 1
Singapore3.099
- 2
Estonia2.768
- 3
Germany2.743
- 4
Denmark2.691
- 5
Luxembourg2.374
Lowest
- 176
Belarus-2.367
- 175
Afghanistan-2.172
- 174
Sudan-2.015
- 173
Turkmenistan-1.893
- 172
Eritrea-1.832
A higher value is the better result. The middle country reads 0.334. “Shared” marks a value another country also holds.
032022 → 2023
Since 2022
- +0 / −0countries joined / left
- 56values changed, of 176 in both
- 32 · 24rose · fell
- 120unchanged
Rose most
Fiji-0.277 → 0.765+1.042
Niger-0.944 → -0.032+0.912
Equatorial Guinea-2.101 → -1.565+0.536
Honduras-0.686 → -0.157+0.529
Syria-2.010 → -1.513+0.497
Fell most
Paraguay-0.085 → -0.902−0.817
Sudan-1.398 → -2.015−0.617
Uganda1.490 → 0.941−0.549
Nicaragua-1.282 → -1.831−0.549
Philippines1.240 → 0.710−0.530
04Caveats
Read before you use
One year of the 2026 release
Every year in this series comes from V-Dem Institute’s 2026 release, recalculated on one method, so a change from one year to the next is not a revision. It can differ from what was first published for 2023.
173 distinct values among 176
Values are stored exactly as published, to 3 decimals. 2 countries share 1.201. Countries sharing a value share a position too.
Nothing missing
Every one of the 176 countries has every column.
05The files
Download and cite
- .csv
For a spreadsheet or code
176 rows · 4.9 KB · UTF-8, opens in Excel
Opens with 11 lines of source notes; the table starts on row 13.
Download meritocratic-appointment-2023-nations-inquiry.csv - ↗
The publisher’s original
V-Dem Institute’s own file, on its own site.
V-Dem-CY-FullOthers-v16_csv.zip
What this site changed: Reshaped to one row per country, with its ISO code; no value recalculated, rescaled or rounded. In full
Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 · what it allows, in plain words
Cite this edition
V-Dem Institute, University of Gothenburg (2023). Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration, 2023 [data set], describing 2023. As held by Nations Inquiry, https://nationsinquiry.com/datasets/meritocratic-appointment/2023
0636 held
Other years
‹ The year before
Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration, 2022176 countries
The year after ›
Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration, 2024176 countries
All of them
Meritocratic Appointment in the State Administration: every year36 held, with the data dictionary, coverage and licence.
How it has moved, charted by country